notanswer

Are You a Maximizer or a Satisficer?

Barry Schwartz's research on how we make decisions

Inspired by Schwartz et al. (2002) — The Paradox of Choice

12 questions · ~4 min

About this reflection tool

Are You a Maximizer or a Satisficer? is a short reflection exercise for moments when the same question keeps circling and another opinion is not making the next step clearer. It uses 12 prompts and takes about 4 minutes.

It is not advice, diagnosis, or a prediction. Treat the result as a mirror: useful when it helps you notice relief, resistance, or the tradeoff you have been trying not to name.

Research basis last reviewed: May 22, 2026.

How to use it well

  1. 1. Hold one real question in mind instead of answering in the abstract.
  2. 2. Choose the closest honest answer, not the answer that sounds best.
  3. 3. After the result, notice what you immediately want to argue with.

What your result can reveal

The Maximizer

You're searching for the best option that doesn't exist yet.

You hold everything to the highest standard — yourself, your choices, your relationships. That's not a flaw. But it means you often leave decisions feeling vaguely unsatisfied, even when you chose well. The best option is a moving target. Every choice you make closes the door on something else, and you feel that closing keenly. Research shows maximizers tend to achieve objectively better outcomes, but report feeling worse about them. The question isn't whether you can make perfect decisions. It's whether perfect decisions are even what you're after.

The Satisficer

You know when good enough is actually good.

You have criteria. When something meets them, you stop looking. This looks like low standards from the outside; from the inside, it's a kind of quiet confidence. Satisficers consistently report higher life satisfaction than maximizers — not because they lower their expectations, but because they don't let the search consume the having. You've probably already decided. You're just giving yourself time to make peace with it.

The Moderate

You maximise for what matters, and let the rest go.

You're selective about where you spend your decision-making energy. Some things deserve exhaustive search; others don't — and you've developed a rough sense of which is which. This is probably the most functional position. You care enough to make good choices, but not so much that choice itself becomes the problem. The hard part is staying honest about which category a decision actually belongs in.